A Capella Music: Killing It or Keeping It?

THE GREATEST THREAT TO A CAPPELLA WORSHIP IS NOT INSTRUMENTAL MUSIC; IT IS LOUSY WORSHIP.

Some church leaders believe they can keep a cappella alive by preaching against instrumental music semi-annually, but the most effective method is to worship the Lord with consistent, spirit-filled praise. When it comes to the perseverance of a cappella Christian hymnody, in some circles, it has become its own worst enemy.

Ensuring there is “nothing wrong” with our worship will not make it worth preserving. The next generation will not adopt their parents rote, lifeless tradition simply upon the premise that it “isn’t wrong.” They will need to experience genuine, heartfelt, spiritual worship. Meaningless, empty worship that is performed without much thought leaves people feeling unfulfilled and longing for something more. If shallow, lousy worship is all they know, that may be the perfect segue into superficial praise team or instrumental worship… “At least it sounds better!”

A cappella worship done well may thrive because it is counter-cultural, not in spite of that fact. So don’t apologize or feel embarrassed because your church doesn’t have a band! Our worship may be the very thing outsiders come to experience. Any art form practiced with skill and passion will likely perpetuate, even as cultural shifts occur around it.

Part tradition, part doctrine, the church holds dear its rich heritage of a cappella worship. The term “a cappella” means “in the style of the chapel.” Simply put, vocal only–without instrumental accompaniment. First century Christians worshiped this way (Colossians 3:16, 17; Ephesians 5:18-20). But God left to our liberty certain methods and mechanics.

Four-part harmony choral music is merely one style of several that Christians have used over the centuries. The main alternative would be unison singing. Unison singing is every bit as acceptable and worshipful as part singing. Many songwriters will sometimes vary between unison and harmony to illustrate unity corresponding to appropriate hymn text phrases (e.g. Come, Thou Almighty King). There is no right or wrong here. It is a matter of stylistic preference. Each may be effective means of worship and communication. The early Christians employed chants and call and response hymns. Four-part harmony choral music is nothing more than a tradition. However, it has many merits that I believe are worth preserving. If church leaders are ignorant or indifferent toward the methods that built and sustain a cappella four-part harmony singing in the church, it is only a matter of time until it is lost.

I have observed that the fundamental building blocks of four part harmony a cappella singing are slowly being forgotten in the church. Many churches have carelessly tossed aside various methods such as pitch pipes and shaped notes while seemingly innocuously “micing” in a praise team… and they act stunned when the harmony disappears and the church stops singing enthusiastically!

12 ways to keep a cappella worship alive:

1. Teach your church who we worship: our awesome God!
2. Teach your church why we worship: He loves us and redeemed us!
3. Teach your church how we worship: in spirit (intellect, emotion, will) and in truth!
4. Appoint men to oversee the worship who understand every aspect of worship and worship leading because of their own experience or else their regular attendance of Singing School with the worship leaders.
5. Carefully select and teach an edited repertoire of songs that are worshipful, edifying, accessible for non-musicians, and purposefully written for congregational singing.
6. Provide hymnals and slides with shaped notes.
7. Train your worship leaders and attempt to use only trained leaders in your main worship.
8. Train your church on the basics of shaped notes, sight singing, dynamics, pitch, and rhythm so they can follow the leader, learn new songs faster, and worship at home.
9. Introduce fresh content at an appropriate rate for your church’s ability (perhaps learn 12 additional songs per year, more or less)
10. Host well-coordinated worship events with skilled leaders and a planned theme including monthly on Sundays and annually in an area-wide event—do it so well that people come from miles around and pack the building to join in praise!
11. Worship at home and in the car with your family.
12. Consult with worship leaders, acoustical engineers, and audio/visual specialists to ensure the building and tech helps the singing.

12 ways to kill a cappella worship:

1. Never bring lessons that directly evoke awe and worship of God—keep it academic and devoid of emotion.
2. Don’t teach why we worship God, only that we must.
3. Don’t teach how we worship God, except to hammer that it must be a cappella—and devoid of emotion.
4. Appoint men to oversee the worship who know little to nothing about worship and therefore cannot understand how the decisions they make are detrimental to the worship.
5. Display conventional notation or “lyrics only” on a trendy inspirational background because you “really want to sing that new radio song” and don’t think anyone reads the shapes or music (you’re wrong).
6. Leave the repertoire to chance with no standards or clear leadership so that you can bore the church with tired old mediocre songs, weird them out with cheesy camp songs, or confuse them with conflicting arrangements–be sure to try to force the church to sing songs written for professional bands and praise teams.
7. Don’t train your worship leaders–let anybody lead who says they’re a song leader.
8. Don’t train your church because you’re sure nobody needs or wants to understand how to read music.
9. Either introduce too few new songs or too many for your group’s desire and ability so that the worship either becomes stale or else feels like a sight singing class.
10. Center all of your churches activities and events around preaching–never or rarely hold special worship services, and when you do, do it so poorly that nobody attends.
11. Let the singing become that weird thing we do at church, and nowhere else, and even then, we do it poorly.
12. Have men who know nothing about worship build an acoustically dead building and use tech that distracts more than it helps.

“I tell you, if these were silent, the very stones would cry out.” Luke 19:40 ESV

My life flows on in endless song – above earth’s lamentation I hear the real though far-off hymn – that hails a new creation: Thru all the tumult and the strife – I hear its music ringing; It sounds an echo in my soul – How can I keep from singing? – Robert W. Lowery, 1868